3 : Consciousness and Intelligence
In the previous chapter, we reached a question that I find difficult to put aside:
Can consciousness understand itself?
This question becomes even more interesting today because human beings have created something that appears, in some ways, to be intelligent.
We call it artificial intelligence, or AI.
A computer can now write an essay, translate languages, recognize patterns, answer questions, compose music, analyse enormous quantities of information and even carry on a conversation with us.
Naturally, this raises a question:
Is AI intelligent in the same sense that a human being is intelligent?
And behind that question is another one:
What do we actually mean by intelligence?
Intelligence and consciousness
We often use the words intelligence and consciousness as though they mean the same thing.
They may not.
A system can process information without necessarily having a conscious experience.
A calculator can perform a calculation.
A thermostat can respond to temperature.
A computer can process enormous amounts of data.
None of these facts, by themselves, tell us whether the system has an inner experience.
Human beings have something that is much harder to explain.
We do not merely process information.
We experience the world.
We see a sunset and can feel wonder.
We hear music and can be moved by it.
.We remember a person who is no longer with us.
We experience pain.
We experience happiness.
We know that we exist.
And perhaps most mysteriously, we can ask:
"Why am I experiencing anything at all?"
This is where the problem of consciousness begins.
![]()
The computer and the human being
Suppose I give a computer millions of photographs.
It can be trained to identify a face.
Suppose I give it thousands of books.
It can find relationships between words and ideas.
Suppose I give it enough information about a language.
It can translate one language into another.
These are remarkable achievements.
But imagine that I ask the computer:
"What does a beautiful sunset feel like to you?"
It may produce an excellent answer.
But producing an answer and actually experiencing a sunset may be two different things.
This is an important distinction.
We must not assume that because a machine behaves intelligently, it necessarily has an inner life like ours.
At the same time, we should be careful about claiming the opposite with complete certainty.
We do not yet have a universally accepted test that tells us exactly what consciousness is, or precisely what conditions are required for it.
So we should keep the question open.
![]()
How do we know that another person is conscious?
There is a simple difficulty here.
I know that I am conscious.
I experience my own thoughts and feelings directly.
But how do I know that another human being is conscious?
I cannot enter another person's mind.
I observe behaviour.
I listen to what the person says.
I see expressions of pain, happiness, fear and affection.
I assume that another person has an inner experience similar in some respects to mine.
This assumption is so natural that we rarely question it.
But philosophically, it is interesting.
We infer another person's inner experience from what we can observe.
If one day a machine behaves in ways that are indistinguishable from a conscious human being, the question becomes much more difficult.
Would we say that it is conscious?
Or would we say that it is merely extraordinarily good at imitating consciousness?
I do not think we should answer this too quickly.
![]()
The strange possibility of other minds
Now let us go one step further.
Suppose intelligence exists somewhere else in the universe.
The universe is unimaginably large.
There are enormous numbers of stars, and many stars have planets.
It is therefore reasonable to ask whether life, and perhaps intelligent life, exists elsewhere.
But there is a deeper question.
If another intelligent civilization exists, must its intelligence resemble ours?
Perhaps not.
Human intelligence developed through the particular history of life on Earth.
Another form of life could have developed under completely different conditions.
Its senses might be different.
Its way of communicating might be different.
Its concept of individuality might be different.
Its understanding of time might even be very different from ours.
And if such a civilization had existed for millions of years longer than ours, its understanding of reality could be so far beyond ours that communication might itself become a problem.
We would be like the blind men again.
We might encounter something intelligent but fail to understand what kind of intelligence we were encountering.
![]()
The Cosmic Computer
This brings us back to an idea that has appeared several times in our discussions.
Could the universe itself be understood, at least metaphorically, as a kind of Cosmic Computer?
The comparison is tempting.
A computer processes information according to rules.
The universe also appears to behave according to regularities that we describe as laws of nature.
A computer can produce complex results from relatively simple rules.
Nature can also produce extraordinary complexity from relatively simple physical processes.
A computer can contain enormous amounts of information.
The universe certainly contains an extraordinary amount of information.
But we must be careful.
The fact that the universe can be described using information and mathematical laws does not prove that the universe literally is a computer.
That is a hypothesis or metaphor, not an established scientific fact.
I find the idea useful because it gives us another way of asking a very old question:
Is there some underlying order beneath the complexity we see?
But the metaphor must not become a conclusion before the evidence exists.
![]()
Who wrote the rules?
If we imagine the universe as a system governed by rules, another question naturally follows:
Where did the rules come from?
This is where science and philosophy begin to touch one another.
Science can investigate the laws we observe.
It can ask whether those laws are fundamental or whether they emerge from something deeper.
It can search for more comprehensive theories.
But the question "Why are there laws at all?" may take us beyond what experiment alone can settle.
Some people may answer:
God created the laws.
Others may say:
The laws simply exist.
Others may believe that what we call laws are emergent features of a deeper physical reality.
Still others may say that the question itself is wrongly framed.
I do not think this book should decide the matter for the reader.
The question is more interesting when we allow the possibilities to remain open.
![]()
The mystery of consciousness
There is, however, a problem that the Cosmic Computer metaphor cannot easily solve.
A computer can process information.
But where does experience come from?
If a machine processes the information that sunlight has a particular wavelength, that is one thing.
A human being can experience sunlight as beautiful.
The physical description and the experience are not obviously the same thing.
This is why consciousness remains such a difficult problem.
We know that consciousness is closely associated with the brain.
We know that changes in the brain can change memory, perception, personality and behaviour.
But exactly how physical processes give rise to subjective experience remains a profound question.
Perhaps future science will explain it.
Perhaps our present understanding is simply incomplete.
Perhaps the problem requires a new conceptual framework.
We do not know.
And saying "we do not know" is not a weakness.
It is an honest description of where the inquiry stands.
![]()
What about the soul?
This is where spiritual traditions enter the discussion.
Many traditions have proposed that consciousness is not merely a product of the physical body.
Some speak of a soul.
Some speak of Ātman.
Some describe consciousness in other ways.
These are important ideas, but we should not turn them into scientific facts merely because they are ancient.
At the same time, science should not be used as a reason to dismiss every spiritual question.
There is a difference between saying:
"Science has not established this."
and saying:
"Therefore this cannot possibly exist."
The first is a statement about evidence.
The second is a much stronger philosophical conclusion.
I think we should maintain that distinction.
![]()
Perhaps intelligence has many forms
When we began this chapter, we were asking whether AI is intelligent.
Now I think the question has become larger.
Perhaps intelligence itself has many forms.
Human intelligence is one form.
Machine intelligence may be another.
An extraterrestrial civilization, if one exists, might represent another.
And perhaps there are forms of intelligence that we have not even imagined.
But consciousness may not necessarily accompany every form of intelligence.
This distinction could become very important as AI develops.
A machine may become extraordinarily capable without becoming conscious.
Or perhaps one day we will discover that consciousness can arise in ways we had not anticipated.
At present, we should not pretend to know.
![]()
And then comes the most difficult question
There is something else that troubles me.
If consciousness is the means through which we experience reality, then perhaps our search for reality can never be completely separated from consciousness itself.
We began with the elephant.
We then asked about the Infinite.
We looked at Nirākāra and Sākāra.
Now we are looking at consciousness.
The direction of our inquiry seems to be changing.
At first, I thought we were searching for something outside us.
Now I am beginning to wonder whether we must also examine what is within us.
Kabir's musk deer comes to mind again.
The deer searches the forest for the fragrance that is already within itself.
And Ramana Maharshi's question becomes relevant:
"Who am I?"
Perhaps that is not a question only for saints and philosophers.
Perhaps it is the most ordinary question of all.
Every one of us can ask it.
And perhaps, before we ask whether the universe is a Cosmic Computer, whether God exists, or whether intelligence exists elsewhere in the cosmos, we should ask something much closer to home:
What is this "I" that is asking all these questions?
That is where our journey must go next.
Comments
Post a Comment