2 : The Finite and the Infinite
After thinking about the blind men and the elephant, another question naturally comes to mind.
If the elephant represents the whole of reality, and we are
able to experience only a part of it, how can a finite human being
understand something that may be infinite?
This question has been troubling human beings for a very
long time.
We are finite.
Our lives have a beginning and an end. Our bodies occupy a
very small space. Our senses are limited. Even our greatest instruments have
limitations.
And yet we can think about the Infinite.
We can think about a universe that may contain billions of
galaxies. We can think about time stretching billions of years into the past.
We can imagine space continuing beyond anything we could ever reach.
But there is a difference between imagining the
Infinite and actually understanding it.
I can say "infinite."
I can even understand what the word means.
But can I actually imagine something that has no end?
Perhaps not.
A small
part of a very large whole
There is an image I find helpful here.
Think of a drop of water in the ocean.
The drop is small. The ocean is enormous.
The drop cannot contain the ocean's vastness. But the
substance of the drop is not foreign to the ocean.
We are also small parts of an enormous reality.
Our lives are short compared with the age of the universe.
Our physical presence is insignificant compared with the
size of the cosmos.
And yet we are made from the same universe that we are
trying to understand.
This is what fascinates me.
The universe has produced beings who can ask
questions about the universe.
A human being can look at the night sky and ask what
existed before the stars.
We can ask how the universe began.
We can ask whether it has an end.
We can ask whether there is something beyond what we can
observe.
And then we can ask the most difficult question of all:
How did we ourselves come to be capable of asking
these questions?
The
finite and the Infinite
When we use the word "Infinite", we should be
careful.
In mathematics, infinity has a particular meaning.
If I start counting:
1, 2, 3, 4, 5...
I can always add another number.
There is no final natural number.
Mathematics has developed precise ways of dealing with
infinity.
But when a spiritual tradition speaks of the Infinite, it
may be talking about something very different.
It may mean the ultimate reality.
It may mean something without limitation.
It may mean that which cannot be contained within ordinary
human concepts.
So we should not casually say that mathematical infinity
and the spiritual idea of the Infinite are the same thing.
They are different ideas.
But the comparison does give us something to think about.
In both cases, we encounter the limits of ordinary human
experience.
Nirākāra
and Sākāra
This brings me to two words that have become important in
my own thinking:
Nirākāra and Sākāra.
Nirākāra means formless.
Sākāra means having form.
The distinction is simple to say but difficult to
understand fully.
We live in a world of forms.
We see people.
We see trees.
We see mountains.
We see stars.
We see the human body.
Almost everything we ordinarily experience has some form.
So when we try to think about something beyond form, the
mind faces a difficulty.
How do you imagine something that has no form?
The moment you try to imagine it, you seem to give it some
form in your mind.
Perhaps this is one reason human beings have created forms
through which they can approach the Divine.
A form makes the invisible easier for the human mind to
approach.
But another person may say that the Divine cannot be
confined to any form.
That is the idea of Nirākāra.
I find this distinction fascinating because it raises a
question that goes beyond religion:
Can something formless express itself through form
without becoming limited to that form?
I do not claim to have an answer.
But this question may become important later.
Why do
we need forms?
Think about language.
We cannot hold an idea in our hands.
Yet we give it a word.
We cannot see love.
Yet we give it expression through actions.
We cannot see mathematics.
Yet we write equations.
We cannot see an idea.
Yet we put it into a book.
Perhaps human beings have always used forms to approach
things that cannot themselves be completely captured by form.
A symbol can point beyond itself.
A word can point toward an idea.
An image can point toward something that the image itself
is not.
Perhaps a religious form can work in a similar way.
But there is a danger.
We may forget that the symbol is a symbol and begin to
believe that the symbol itself contains the whole reality.
This brings us back to the elephant.
The part must not be mistaken for the whole.
The Pūrṇam mantra
There is an ancient Sanskrit mantra that has stayed in my
mind:
ॐ पूर्णमदः पूर्णमिदं
पूर्णात् पूर्णमुदच्यते।
पूर्णस्य पूर्णमादाय
पूर्णमेवावशिष्यते॥
It is commonly understood in terms of wholeness or
completeness:
That is whole. This is whole.
From the whole, the whole arises.
When the whole is taken from the whole,
the whole still remains.
I find this difficult to understand in an ordinary physical
sense.
If I have one apple and take a piece from it, the original
apple is reduced.
If I divide a physical object, each part is smaller than
the original.
So what kind of "whole" is being described here?
Perhaps the mantra is pointing toward an idea of wholeness
that is different from an ordinary physical object.
I would not claim that it is a prediction of modern physics
or mathematics.
It is not a scientific equation.
But as a philosophical thought, it is extraordinary.
It makes us ask:
Can the whole be present in the part without being
exhausted by the part?
That is a question worth keeping with us.
A
thought from mathematics
There is another idea that comes to mind when I think about
the relationship between whole and part.
In mathematics, differentiation and integration move in
somewhat opposite directions.
Differentiation helps us examine what is happening locally,
at a particular point.
Integration helps us gather contributions together to
understand a larger quantity.
I am not suggesting that calculus proves any spiritual
idea.
It does not.
But the comparison is useful to me.
We often understand the world by breaking it into parts.
Physics studies one aspect.
Biology another.
Astronomy another.
Psychology another.
Philosophy another.
Religion another.
This division helps us understand things more clearly.
But after dividing reality into parts, we face another
problem:
How do all these parts belong to the same whole?
Perhaps we need both movements.
We need to differentiate, so that we can
understand the parts.
And we need to integrate, so that we do
not forget the whole.
We are
part of what we study
There is something still more remarkable.
When we study the universe, we are not studying something
completely separate from ourselves.
We are part of it.
The atoms in our bodies have a history that goes back long
before human beings appeared.
The Earth is part of the universe.
Life developed on Earth.
The human brain developed through the history of life.
And now that brain is trying to understand the universe
from which it emerged.
I find this almost astonishing.
A part of the universe is trying to understand the
whole of which it is a part.
Perhaps that is one reason the question of consciousness is
so important.
We can look at a star.
We can study a stone.
We can examine a living cell.
But then we come to ourselves.
We can also look at our own thoughts.
We can wonder why we experience pain, happiness, beauty,
fear and love.
We can ask what consciousness actually is.
And then the question becomes even more difficult:
Can consciousness understand itself?
The
bridge we have been looking for
Earlier, we were searching for a bridge between Nirākāra
and Sākāra, between the Infinite and the finite.
Perhaps we should not expect a simple bridge.
Perhaps the relationship is more subtle.
The Infinite cannot simply be squeezed into a finite
description.
The formless cannot be completely represented by a form.
But the finite can perhaps point toward the Infinite.
A form can perhaps point beyond itself.
A mathematical equation can reveal a relationship without
becoming the reality it describes.
A scientific theory can describe nature without becoming
nature itself.
A poem can point toward something that cannot be fully
explained.
And perhaps a human life can point toward something greater
than the individual.
I am not saying that these things are the same.
I am only wondering whether they have something in common.
Where
does the search take us?
We began with the blind men.
Then we asked whether human knowledge is necessarily
partial.
Now we have arrived at another possibility.
Perhaps the greatest limitation is not merely that we
cannot see enough of the universe.
Perhaps the limitation is that we are trying to
understand the universe using an instrument whose own nature we do not
completely understand.
That instrument is the human mind.
And behind the mind is consciousness.
So perhaps the next question is unavoidable:
What is consciousness, and how did it come to be?
If human beings can think, imagine, remember and
understand, then what does that tell us about the universe that produced them?
And now, in our own time, we have created something new.
We have begun building machines that can process
information, learn patterns and produce what appears to be intelligent
behaviour.
We call it artificial intelligence.
That brings us to our next chapter:
Consciousness and Intelligence: Humans, AI, and the
Possibility of Other Minds
Comments
Post a Comment