4 : The Search Within

In the last chapter, we reached a question that looks very simple:

Who am I?

At first, it may seem like the easiest question in the world.

I know my name.

I know where I was born.

I know my family.

I know my profession, my memories, my likes and dislikes.

So what is there to ask?

But if we keep asking the question, things become less certain.

My name is not really me. It is a name given to me.

My body changes throughout life, yet I continue to say, "I am the same person."

My thoughts also change.

What I believed twenty years ago may not be what I believe today.

My memories change too. Some become clearer, some disappear, and some may even be mistaken.

Yet behind all these changes there is a persistent feeling:

I am.

What is this "I"?

The changing body

Look at a photograph of yourself from childhood.

The person in the photograph may look very different from the person you are today.

The body has changed.

The face has changed.

The voice has changed.

Even the cells of the body are continuously being replaced and renewed.

Yet we do not normally say:

"That was another person."

We say:

"That was me."

So there is some sense of continuity even though the physical body has changed enormously.

What provides that continuity?

Perhaps memory.

But memory alone does not seem to explain everything.

We sometimes forget important parts of our lives.

We can lose memories and still remain the same person.

So perhaps the "I" is not simply the collection of memories.

The changing mind

The same thing happens with the mind.

Our thoughts are constantly changing.

One moment we are happy.

Another moment we are worried.

Then we become angry.

Later we calm down.

We can change our opinions, our ambitions and even our beliefs.

But we say:

"I was angry."

"I was happy."

"I changed my mind."

Notice the language.

We say I had a thought.

We say I experienced sadness.

We say I changed my opinion.

This seems to suggest that the thoughts and emotions are something we experience, rather than the complete definition of who we are.

But then who is the one experiencing them?

The observer

Imagine that you are sitting quietly and watching your own thoughts.

A thought appears.

You notice it.

Another thought appears.

You notice that too.

Sometimes the mind becomes quiet.

Then another thought comes.

If you can observe a thought, it is natural to ask:

Who is observing it?

This question has occupied Indian philosophers and spiritual seekers for centuries.

The Upanishadic tradition, Vedanta and later teachers have explored the distinction between the changing experiences of the individual and that which is aware of them.

Different schools interpret this differently, and I do not want to pretend that they all say exactly the same thing.

But the question itself is powerful.

Am I only the thoughts that pass through my mind, or am I also the one who is aware of those thoughts?

Kabir's musk deer

At this point, I remember Kabir:

कस्तूरी कुंडल बसै,
मृग ढूंढ़े बन माहि।
ऐसे घटि-घटि राम हैं,
दुनिया देखत नाहिं॥

The musk deer searches through the forest for the fragrance whose source is within itself.

Kabir uses the image to point toward something much deeper.

Perhaps human beings also spend their lives searching outside themselves for something that may require an inward search.

We look for happiness in possessions.

We look for security in wealth.

We look for recognition from other people.

We search for God in distant places.

Yet perhaps we have not first asked:

Who is the one who is searching?

I am not saying that this proves that God is within us.

It is a spiritual idea, not a scientific conclusion.

But it is a beautiful question.

And sometimes a good question is more valuable than a quick answer.

"Who am I?"

This brings us to Ramana Maharshi.

His teaching repeatedly returned to the question:

"Who am I?"

It sounds almost too simple.

We might expect a spiritual teacher to give us a complicated theory about God, the universe or the soul.

Instead, the question is turned back toward the seeker.

Who is this "I"?

If I say, "I am my body," then what happens when the body changes?

If I say, "I am my thoughts," what happens when thoughts change?

If I say, "I am my memories," what happens when memories disappear?

The questioning can continue.

Perhaps the purpose is not to find a clever verbal answer.

Perhaps the purpose is to look closely at the one who is asking.

The search changes direction

At the beginning of our journey, we were looking outward.

We looked at the universe.

We wondered about its size and origin.

We thought about the Infinite.

We wondered about God.

We considered whether the universe might be compared with a Cosmic Computer.

But now the direction has changed.

We are looking inward.

This does not mean that the external world is unimportant.

Far from it.

Science will continue to take us outward.

Telescopes will continue to look into space.

Microscopes will continue to look into the very small.

Physics will continue to search for deeper laws.

Artificial intelligence will continue to explore the possibilities of information and computation.

But alongside all this outward exploration, there is another journey.

The journey into the observer.

Perhaps the two searches are connected

Here I want to be careful.

I am not saying that modern science has proved the teachings of Kabir or Ramana Maharshi.

It has not.

Nor am I saying that spiritual experience provides a substitute for scientific investigation.

It does not.

But both science and spiritual inquiry can begin with a similar attitude:

Do not accept something merely because you have been told it. Look. Examine. Question.

The scientist turns the instrument toward nature.

The spiritual seeker turns attention toward the self.

The instruments are different.

The methods are different.

The questions are different.

But there is a common spirit of inquiry.

Perhaps that is where a meaningful conversation between science and spirituality can begin.

The mystery remains

After all this, I still cannot give a final answer to the question:

Who am I?

Perhaps nobody can give it to another person.

A dictionary can define words.

A philosopher can offer an argument.

A scripture can offer guidance.

A teacher can point toward a path.

But ultimately, the question has to be examined by the person who asks it.

This is where our journey becomes deeply personal.

The universe may contain billions of galaxies.

There may be realities we cannot see.

There may be forms of intelligence we have not encountered.

There may even be aspects of nature that our present science cannot yet explain.

But before trying to solve all those mysteries, perhaps we should pause before the smallest mystery of all:

the fact that I am here, aware, asking questions.

And that brings us back to the title of our book.

The blind men were trying to understand the elephant.

Perhaps humanity is doing something similar with reality.

Each of us touches a part.

Science touches one part.

Philosophy another.

Religion another.

Personal experience another.

Perhaps none of us should be too quick to claim that our particular piece is the whole.

But there is one thing we can do.

We can continue asking.

And perhaps the next question should be:

If consciousness is the instrument through which we know the world, where did consciousness itself come from?

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

3 : Consciousness and Intelligence

11: The Mystery of Consciousness

6 : The Question of God