5 : The World We Experience

 We have been asking where consciousness comes from.

Before trying to answer that question, perhaps we should take a small step back and ask something more familiar:

What exactly is the world we experience?

At first, the answer seems obvious.

The table is there.

The chair is there.

The tree is there.

The sky is there.

I see them, touch them and move among them.

So what could be complicated about it?

Yet the moment we think about how we actually experience the world, the question becomes surprisingly interesting.

We do not experience the world directly

Consider colour.

We say that a flower is red.

But what reaches our eyes is not the word "red."

Light reaches the eye. The eye responds to particular wavelengths. Signals travel through the nervous system, and the brain processes them.

Somehow, out of this process, we experience red.

The same applies to sound.

A musical note reaches our ears as vibrations in the air.

The ear converts those vibrations into signals.

The brain processes them.

And we experience a sound.

The physical process and our experience of it are connected, but they are not described in exactly the same language.

This is worth remembering.

The world that physics describes and the world that we experience are related, but our experience is not simply a photograph of reality.

Our senses and our brain are involved in constructing our experience.

The narrow window

Our senses are remarkably useful, but they cover only a small range of what exists physically.

Human beings see only a limited portion of the electromagnetic spectrum.

There are radio waves, microwaves, infrared radiation, ultraviolet radiation, X-rays and gamma rays that our eyes do not see.

They are not therefore unreal.

We simply do not experience them directly through ordinary vision.

Our instruments extend our senses.

A radio telescope detects things our eyes cannot see.

An X-ray instrument reveals things invisible to ordinary light.

A microscope reveals structures too small for our unaided eyes.

This has changed our understanding of reality again and again.

It also teaches us something important.

Not seeing something is not the same as proving that it does not exist.

But the reverse is equally important.

Not seeing something does not prove that a particular unseen thing exists.

We must keep both thoughts together.

Light gives us a wonderful example

Light has fascinated scientists for centuries.

For a long time, scientists argued about whether light should be understood as a wave or as particles.

Experiments eventually showed that light displays properties associated with both descriptions.

This is one of the places where nature refuses to fit neatly into our everyday categories.

We tend to think:

"It must be either this or that."

Nature sometimes tells us:

"Your categories are too simple."

Quantum physics deepened this mystery.

At very small scales, the behaviour of nature does not always resemble the world we experience directly.

We should not take this as permission to say that every spiritual idea has therefore been proved by quantum mechanics.

It has not.

But quantum physics does provide a humbling lesson:

Reality can be stranger than our everyday picture of it.

The wave and the particle

This reminds me of our earlier discussion about Sākāra and Nirākāra.

One should be careful here.

A wave-particle description in physics is not the same thing as the philosophical distinction between form and formlessness.

They belong to different intellectual traditions.

But there is an interesting resemblance in the question they provoke.

We often want reality to fit into one familiar category.

Physics sometimes forces us to accept a more complicated description.

Spiritual philosophy can similarly ask whether ultimate reality can be confined to the forms through which human beings approach it.

Perhaps the lesson is not that physics proves spirituality.

Perhaps the lesson is much simpler:

We should be cautious about assuming that our ordinary categories exhaust reality.

What happens when we look at a tree?

Let us return to something ordinary.

Look at a tree.

You see its trunk, branches and leaves.

You may notice its colour and shape.

You may hear the movement of its leaves.

You may touch its bark.

But beneath this familiar appearance is an extraordinary complexity.

Cells are working.

Water is moving.

Chemical reactions are taking place.

Energy from sunlight is being transformed.

Molecules are interacting.

The tree is part of an ecosystem.

The ecosystem is part of the Earth.

The Earth is part of the solar system.

The solar system is part of the galaxy.

The galaxy is part of the universe.

Where does the tree end?

At the boundary of its bark?

Or should we include the air it exchanges, the water it absorbs, the sunlight that sustains it and the organisms that live with it?

The simple object becomes less simple the more closely we look.

The part and the whole

We are again approaching the question that appeared in the Pūrṇam mantra.

Perhaps our difficulty is partly caused by the way we divide reality.

We give things names.

Tree.

Stone.

Human being.

Star.

Planet.

Animal.

These names are useful.

Without them, ordinary communication would be impossible.

But nature itself does not necessarily respect the boundaries created by our words.

The tree depends upon the soil.

The soil depends upon countless organisms.

The tree depends upon sunlight and water.

Animals depend upon plants.

Plants depend upon the atmosphere.

The atmosphere depends upon processes involving the oceans, land and living organisms.

Everything seems to be connected with something else.

We separate things in order to understand them.

But then we must remember that our divisions are also descriptions.

They are not necessarily the ultimate boundaries of reality.

Where does the observer fit?

Now we return to ourselves.

I can look at a tree.

I can measure it.

I can photograph it.

I can study its chemistry.

I can describe its biological processes.

But the moment I ask what it means to me, another element enters the picture.

The observer.

The tree is being studied by a conscious being.

That conscious being has memories, expectations, emotions and purposes.

A scientist studying a tree and a child sitting beneath the same tree may experience very different things.

The physical tree has not necessarily changed.

The experience has.

This does not mean that reality is merely whatever we want it to be.

The tree does not disappear because nobody looks at it.

It means that our experience of reality is shaped partly by the observer.

This is an important distinction.

Are we living in a picture of reality?

Perhaps what we experience is something like a model.

The brain receives signals from the senses and constructs a useful representation of the world.

That representation helps us survive.

We do not need to know every molecule in a glass of water before drinking it.

We simply need to recognize the glass, understand its location and reach for it.

Evolution did not necessarily design the human brain to reveal every layer of reality.

It developed within the struggle to survive.

Yet this same brain has now become capable of mathematics, philosophy and science.

That is one of the great surprises of human existence.

The instrument that evolved for survival has become an instrument for questioning existence itself.

From seeing to knowing

There is therefore a difference between seeing something and knowing it completely.

The blind man touching the elephant has an experience.

A sighted person may have a much fuller experience.

A zoologist may know the animal's anatomy.

A physicist may know the properties of its matter.

A biologist may understand its evolution.

Yet none of these descriptions necessarily exhausts what an elephant is.

Perhaps knowledge works like layers.

We begin with experience.

Then we form concepts.

Then we develop theories.

Then we discover that the theory has limits.

Then we ask deeper questions.

And the process begins again.

This may be why the boundary of knowledge keeps moving.

Perhaps this is where science and spirituality meet

Science asks us to examine the world carefully.

Spiritual inquiry asks us to examine the experiencer carefully.

One asks:

What is out there?

The other may ask:

Who is experiencing what is out there?

Perhaps both questions are necessary.

If we look only outward, we may understand the universe better but remain puzzled about the person doing the observing.

If we look only inward, we may gain insights about ourselves but lose contact with the physical world.

The challenge is to hold both directions together.

A bridge, but not yet an answer

We began our inquiry looking for a bridge between the finite and the Infinite, between Sākāra and Nirākāra.

Perhaps we are slowly discovering that the bridge may involve consciousness.

Not because science has proved this.

Not because a scripture has provided a scientific formula.

But because consciousness is where the two questions meet.

There is a universe outside me.

There is an experience of that universe within me.

And there is a mysterious relationship between the two.

I can study the universe.

I can study my brain.

I can study consciousness.

But I am still the one doing the studying.

That leaves us with a rather strange circle.

The observer is trying to understand the instrument by which the observer understands everything else.

Perhaps that is why the question of consciousness is so difficult.

And perhaps it is also why the old question keeps returning:

Who am I?

We have asked it before.

Now we are beginning to see why it may be at the centre of our entire journey.

 

 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

3 : Consciousness and Intelligence

11: The Mystery of Consciousness

6 : The Question of God