7 : The Universe as Information

 

We have now reached an interesting point in our journey.

We started with the blind men and the elephant.

We asked whether any one person can see the whole of reality.

Then we spoke about the finite and the Infinite, about Sākāra and Nirākāra, and about the strange fact that a small human mind can think about the enormous universe.

We asked what consciousness is.

We asked whether God is outside us or whether the search for God may also be a search within ourselves.

Now I want to ask another question:

What if, beneath everything we see, there is information?

I do not mean that the universe is literally a computer.

I am asking whether information might be one of the fundamental ways in which we can understand the universe.

What is information?

We use the word every day.

A book contains information.

A photograph contains information.

A computer file contains information.

A conversation contains information.

Our DNA contains instructions that carry biological information.

Even a simple sentence can change what another person knows.

Information seems to be something different from the physical object that carries it.

A book is made of paper and ink.

But the same information can be printed on paper, stored electronically or spoken aloud.

The physical form can change while the information remains recognizable.

That is what makes information such an interesting idea.

The computer

A computer gives us a simple example.

Inside a computer are physical components.

There are electrical signals, circuits, memory and processors.

Yet what we see on the screen may be a photograph, a letter, a calculation or a piece of music.

The same physical machine can handle completely different kinds of information.

The computer does not need to understand a photograph in the same way a human being understands it. It processes patterns according to its design and instructions.

This made me wonder:

Could nature itself also be understood in terms of information and rules?

The idea is not as strange as it first sounds.

Physics describes nature through mathematical relationships.

A particle behaves according to physical laws.

A chemical reaction follows particular rules.

A living cell contains an extraordinary amount of organized information.

The universe is not simply a collection of unrelated events.

There is order.

There are regularities.

There are relationships.

And mathematics allows us to describe many of them.

But is the universe a computer?

Here we must slow down.

It is tempting to say:

"The universe follows rules, computers follow rules, therefore the universe is a computer."

But that conclusion does not follow.

A river follows physical laws.

That does not make the river a computer.

A crystal forms according to physical rules.

That does not make the crystal a computer.

So the idea of a Cosmic Computer should initially be treated as a way of thinking about the universe, not as an established scientific fact.

Perhaps it is a metaphor.

Perhaps it is a philosophical hypothesis.

Perhaps future science will reveal something much deeper.

At present, we do not know.

And that uncertainty is important.

The rules of the universe

Still, the comparison raises a fascinating question.

A computer cannot do just anything.

Its behaviour depends on its hardware, software and rules.

The universe also has regularities that we call the laws of nature.

The planets move according to gravitational laws.

Light behaves according to physical laws.

Matter interacts according to fundamental forces.

Chemical elements behave according to the structure of atoms.

Life depends upon extraordinarily complex interactions.

The universe therefore does not appear to be a completely random collection of events.

There is order.

And because there is order, we can discover patterns.

Because we can discover patterns, we can construct mathematics.

And because mathematics works so remarkably well in describing nature, we are led to another question:

Why is the universe understandable at all?

Einstein's puzzle

This question has fascinated physicists and philosophers.

Why should mathematics created in the human mind be so effective in describing a universe that existed long before human beings appeared?

We should not turn this into a mystery greater than it is.

Mathematics is, after all, a language developed by human beings to recognize patterns and relationships.

But the effectiveness of mathematics remains remarkable.

We can write an equation on a piece of paper and use it to predict what will happen in the physical world.

The equation does not push the planet around.

It describes the relationship we observe.

Yet the description works.

That relationship between mathematics and nature is one of the great wonders of scientific inquiry.

 

From matter to information

Modern physics has also encouraged us to think differently about matter.

At one time, it was natural to think of the universe as made fundamentally of solid objects.

Tables were solid.

Stones were solid.

The Earth was solid.

Matter seemed straightforward.

Then physics took us deeper.

Atoms were found to contain smaller structures.

The subatomic world turned out to be very different from everyday experience.

Quantum mechanics introduced probabilities and behaviours that challenged our ordinary intuition.

Again, we should not jump from this to the conclusion that "quantum mechanics proves the universe is information."

It does not.

But it does remind us that the world beneath our everyday experience may be very different from the world our senses present to us.

 

Information and life

There is another reason information fascinates me.

 

Life itself appears to depend upon information.

DNA carries biological instructions.

Those instructions are copied, read and used in the processes of living organisms.

A tiny biological structure can contain an extraordinary amount of organized information.

Yet DNA by itself is not the whole story.

The information has to operate within a living system.

Genes interact with cells.

Cells interact with one another.

Organisms interact with their environment.

So again we encounter th

e relationship between information and the system that carries it.

Perhaps this is another reminder that information cannot be separated completely from the physical world in which it operates.

The Cosmic Computer idea

Suppose, only as a thought experiment, that the universe were like an immense computational system.

What would that mean?

It might mean that what we call the laws of nature are like the rules of the system.

Matter and energy would be the physical processes taking place within it.

Information would describe the state of those processes.

Conscious beings would be systems capable of processing information and reflecting upon their own existence.

But then an obvious question appears:

Who or what is running the Cosmic Computer?

This is where the metaphor becomes dangerous.

If we imagine a computer, we naturally imagine a programmer.

But the universe is not known to have been programmed in the way a human computer is programmed.

Perhaps there is no programmer.

Perhaps the laws simply exist.

Perhaps the universe arose from deeper physical principles.

Perhaps our question about a programmer is based entirely on our human experience of computers.

We should not assume an answer merely because the metaphor suggests one.

 

The programmer and God

Yet I cannot completely ignore the philosophical connection.

For thousands of years, people have asked whether the universe has a creator.

Now we have created computers ourselves.

So when we imagine the universe as a computational system, the old question returns in a new form:

Is there an intelligence behind the system?

This is where the scientific question and the spiritual question begin to touch.

But touching is not the same as becoming identical.

Science asks what can be observed and tested.

Philosophy asks what follows from our concepts and assumptions.

Spiritual traditions ask questions about ultimate reality and human existence.

The Cosmic Computer is an idea that sits somewhere between these conversations.

It may help us ask questions.

It does not yet give us answers.

 

The observer inside the system

There is another remarkable feature.

If the universe is a system containing information, then we are not observers standing outside it.

We are inside it.

We are made from matter.

Our brains are physical systems.

Our thoughts arise in connection with activity in those brains.

And yet we can think about the entire system.

It is almost like a character inside a story suddenly becoming aware that there is a story.

I do not know whether that analogy is correct.

But it captures something that I find fascinating.

The universe has produced beings who can represent the universe in their minds.

We can make maps of galaxies.

We can write equations describing the early universe.

We can build computers that simulate physical processes.

We can even build artificial intelligence that processes enormous amounts of information.

The universe is, in some sense, becoming knowable to itself through its conscious inhabitants.

 

And now the question becomes larger

We began by asking:

What is God?

Then:

What is consciousness?

Now we are asking:

What is information?

These questions may appear unrelated.

But perhaps they are three different ways of approaching the same great mystery.

There is something that exists.

There are regularities in what exists.

Those regularities can be described.

Living beings can process information about them.

Some living beings become conscious.

And conscious beings begin asking why any of this exists.

At this point I am reminded again of the blind men and the elephant.

Perhaps information is another part of the elephant.

Perhaps consciousness is another.

Perhaps matter is another.

Perhaps God is the name some people give to the whole.

But we should not assume that we have found the elephant simply because we have identified another part.

 

The journey ahead

The Cosmic Computer is therefore not our final answer.

It is another question.

Perhaps an important one.

If nature can be described through information and mathematical rules, could there be a deeper relationship between matter, information and consciousness?

And if there is such a relationship, could it help us understand the old philosophical distinction between the formless and the formed, between Nirākāra and Sākāra, between the Infinite and the finite?

I do not know.

But now we have reached a point where modern physics enters our story more seriously.

The strange world of quantum mechanics challenges many of our ordinary ideas about reality.

And beyond quantum mechanics lies another ambitious attempt to understand the fundamental structure of nature:

string theory.

Perhaps, as we move there, we will discover another piece of the elephant.

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

3 : Consciousness and Intelligence

11: The Mystery of Consciousness

6 : The Question of God